Thursday, March 29, 2012

Long battle ends in success

A 5 year fight is over following a decision by the UK’s highest Court which now means that employers’ insurers will be obliged to pay compensation claims of those suffering from or the families of those who have died from mesothelioma, a disease that can lay undetected for many years. It means that many thousands of people will at long last be entitled to compensation following the landmark ruling that the liability of insurers arises at the date of exposure to asbestos and not when symptoms of mesothelioma are detected which may be decades later.

Yesterday the Supreme Court delivered a long awaited landmark Judgment in what has been termed the mesothelioma “trigger litigation” which has seen a long running Court battle at an end, the Supreme Court having now ruled that the relevant date for the purposes of entitlement to compensation is the date of exposure and not the date when symptoms may develop or manifest themselves which can be many years later.

This particular issue related to the stance taken by a number of insurers that they were not obliged to pay out on such claims and that the key date for claiming arose at the date that the disease developed. This ruling has ended that argument in confirming that the relevant date is the date of employment during which the exposure occurred.

This will be of some comfort to those who have contracted mesothelioma, an insidious cancer, as well as their loved ones who will be able to pursue claims against the insurers as a result of their exposure to asbestos resulting in them contracting the disease.

For those who are suffering such condition and those who have lost their personal battle but whose families continue to pursue for their just entitlements, this decision brings to an end a whole host of test cases which have challenged the entitlement of those exposed to asbestos being able to recover compensation.

These cases are particularly difficult and raise a variety of complex legal issues. Expertise as well as compassion and the ability to empathise are key elements in ensuring that those who are entitled to compensation secure that compensation.

Rogers & Norton's Personal Injury Department has dealt with a number of significant asbestos cases and to achieve a successful outcome requires stubborn determination and frequently detailed forensic investigation in respect of a client’s employment history. This calls for professionalism, determination and compassion in equal measure.

If you would like to talk to one of our lawyers about whether you may have a possible claim for compensation relating to exposure to asbestos then please contact us on 01603 666001 for a free initial consultation.

Friday, March 16, 2012

Into The Dragon's Den


Mark Hambling partner and personal injury expert at Rogers & Norton swapped his usual role of fighting for justice for personal injury victims to become a dragon in the Brundall School Dragons Den. Joining other local business leaders from Oriental Rugs Norwich, Pymm & Co, Bugdens and Norwich City Football Club, Mark heard seven pitches from business formed by groups of year 6 pupils at Brundall School.

The pitches for investment came from potential businesses ranging from a milkshake and Brownie company, a school fitness DVD and a loyalty scheme encouraging children to eat fruit. Each business obtained investment ranging between £20 and £50 and each dragon will now support the children as they strive to develop their business and make a profit to enable interest to be paid back to the investor.

Mark Hambling, Personal Injury partner, has invested in a fitness DVD company which plans to produce a DVD filmed in the school, using the school pupils to be sold in the summer term in the run up to the Olympics. Commenting on the event Mark said, "Whilst I know little about fitness DVD's, as a parent I know how good it is to see your children on screen or in the press. I therefore hope my teams DVD will certainly sell well to the parents in the Brundall and surrounding area".

The pupils worked very hard in preparing for the event and as part of their studies had prepared business plans, marketing strategies and projections. Their presentation of their business proposals to the Dragons was excellent and they engaged in debate and negotiation with the Dragons in a very professional and measured way. Mark commented " I was very impressed with the pupils enthusiasm and skills and had a thoroughly enjoyable afternoon with a group of very able children".

Rogers & Norton were delighted to be one of the supporters of this event and we hope to see some entrepreneurs develop in the future from these year 6 pupils.

Thanks must also be given to Mr Ed Dooley the year 6 class teacher and Brundall school for their hard work in arranging the event. Further reports and pictures of the pupils can be seen on the front page of the Evening News today (16th March 2012) and in todays Eastern Daily Press.

Mark Hambling can be contacted on 01603 675637 or mbh@rogers-norton.co.uk.

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Nancy and others


The High Court has recently thrown out a libel claim brought by Nancy Dell’Olio against the Daily Mail. A double page spread under the catchy heading “Return of the Man Eater” referred to her relationship with Sir Trevor Nunn.

In any libel claim the Claimant has to specify the allegedly defamatory meaning contained in the words used.  The Claimant’s first attempt was that they meant she is “a serial gold digger and has deliberately set out to snare herself a wealthy man by making their adulterous affair public thereby destroying his marriage for her own personal gain”.   Since the article had itself pointed out that Sir Trevor Nunn’s marriage had already broken down and that it was him pursuing her, not the other way around, that alleged meaning was abandoned in favour of “a serial gold digger who cynically seeks out relationships with men not for genuine emotional reasons but because they are millionaires and therefore capable of funding her conspicuously lavish and ostentatious lifestyle”.

A libel claim can only go forward for decision by a jury if the judge holds that the article was at least “capable of substantially affecting (or tending to affect) in an adverse manner the attitude of other people towards this Claimant”. The article must be read in a reasonable, not strained, way, and read as a whole – not just the headline and not cherry picking out of context.  It is not enough to say that by some person or another the words might be understood in a defamatory way.  The judge has to borrow the mindset of the hypothetical reasonable reader who is taken be representative of all likely readers of the publication.

I always smile at the Court’s approach to this notional being. He is “not naïve but he is not unduly suspicious. He can read between the lines. He can read an implication more readily than a lawyer and may indulge in a certain amount of loose thinking but he must be treated as a man who is not avid for scandal and someone who does not, and should not, select one bad meaning where other non-defamatory meanings are available”.

The Court’s Decision

The Judge found the article “unflattering and even insulting”- but held that the references to lifestyle, money and wealth did not pass “the threshold of seriousness required if a publication is to be capable of being defamatory”. The article was simply not capable of bearing any defamatory meaning, and there was no further decision to be made on this at a full jury trial.

Comment

The case is a useful insight into the judicial approach to the world of celebrity spats, and the workings of the filters built into the litigation process. Not every aggrieved celebrity is always entitled to take her case all the way to a costly trial. Both the defendant (even the Daily Mail) and the public purse need protection from the continued pursuit of litigation which is doomed to fail.

For further information in connection with our libel and commercial disputes practice and the possible use of Conditional Fee Agreements in these areas please contact John Cadywould on 01603 675629 or at jbc@rogers-norton.co.uk.

Tuesday, January 31, 2012

Crime will not pay

CICA Scheme is to be overhauled. Criminals will only be able to claim compensation for being victims of crime in "exceptional circumstances", under proposals by the justice secretary, Mr Ken Clarke. This if after the annual costs of the taxpayer funded scheme trebled to nearly £300m since 1997.

The proposed reforms include:
  1. Criminals to contribute more towards the scheme. Payment of "victim surcharges" by more offenders, and higher fines for driving offences, will it is hoped raise £50m for victims.
  2. To stop criminals claiming for injuries and psychological damage.
  3. Claims for minor injuries under the scheme for people in England, Wales and Scotland would also be restricted under the plans.
  4. A person with a criminal record will only be able to claim compensation in exceptional circumstances. This could include, for example, a minor offender who is very seriously injured or a criminal who prevents someone else being attacked.
Over the past decade, 20,000 people with criminal records have been paid more than £75m, including a rapist and a person convicted of two killings.

Thursday, January 19, 2012

R&N 30th Anniversary Charity Ball

We are delighted to announce our 30th Birthday Celebration on Saturday 2nd June 2012 exactly 30 years to the day from when we first opened our doors.

Our 30th Birthday Ball will be held in a grand traditional Marquee at the stunning location of Colney Hall, Norwich.

This promises to be one of the most lavish events Norwich has ever seen.

The design & decor will be spectacular and Brasteds have been employed to create, prepare and serve an exquisite 4 course dinner.

Invitations will follow in the next few weeks. However, if you would like to reserve tickets please contact me as soon as possible as these are sure to be in great demand. Tickets are priced at £60 per person & will include a Champagne Reception, a 4 course meal with wine, coffee & mints & live music.

All profits & proceeds will benefit Nelsons Journey - a local charity helping Norfolk children cope with bereavement.

Graham Knights
Practice Manager
Rogers & Norton

gjk@rogers-norton.co.uk

01603 675618

Special pantomime party for bereaved children

http://www.eveningnews24.co.uk/news/norwich_solicitors_rogers_and_norton_stage_special_pantomime_party_for_bereaved_children_1_1179100

Friday, January 6, 2012

Directors Liabilities and Duties - how to stay out of trouble!

We are hosting a FREE workshop entitled "Directors Liabilities and Duties - how to stay out of trouble!" at our office at Willow Lane, Norwich on Tues 10th Jan 2012 at 4:30pm.  If you would like to attend please email Simon Kerrison.