Showing posts with label sophie key. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sophie key. Show all posts

Thursday, January 3, 2013

All I Want for Christmas….


You may have read over the Christmas period the rather saddening reports that a ‘dad’ was the tenth most longed-for ‘present’ on children’s Christmas wish lists.
A survey of 2,000 parents, conducted by Westfield London and Westfield Stratford City revealed that, along with the expensive ‘must have’ toys and an array of pets, a number of children wished for a father in their lives.
The survey highlights the breakdown of family life. Recent figures from the Office for National Statistics show that the number of children living in single-parent families in the UK has risen steadily but significantly from 1.6 million in 1996 to 2.0 million in 2012.*
From our dealings with clients we appreciate that it is not always through choice that many fathers, and indeed mothers, are prevented from being involved in their child’s life. Unfortunately, it is not uncommon for the resident parent to be obstructive to the contact between a child and their non-resident parent. We are frequently asked by clients to write to their former partner to negotiate the arrangements for contact (formerly known as access). This is not just at Christmas but is a year-round problem for many families. On some occasions it is necessary for parents to apply to the Family Courts for a Contact Order.
Since April 2011 it is necessary for most cases to be referred to mediation before an application to the Court can be made. Mediation is a process whereby a trained, impartial mediator meets with the parties together and assists them to reach a resolution between themselves. If mediation is unsuccessful then it is possible to make an application to the Court.

In the absence of any welfare concerns the Court operates under a presumption that contact between a child and their non-resident parent is in the best interests of the child. Contact can take many forms including ‘supported’ contact at a local contact centre to ‘staying’ contact. The process may be resolved by agreement at an early stage or may proceed to a final hearing whereby a judge will make a decision as to the type and frequency of contact. The Court treats very seriously the issue of contact between children and their parents and relatively recent developments in the law has seen the introduction of custodial sanctions for resident parents who continue to obstruct contact in breach of a Court order.

If you are experiencing difficulties maintaining contact with your children or you wish for some advice as to how to manage your child’s contact with your former partner please contact our Family Team. We offer a one-off Fixed Fee meeting during which we can address your queries and advise you as to your options. Our fees are £50 + VAT for the Fixed Fee meeting.

Please feel free to contact Sophie Key, Solicitor, or Amy Walpole, Partner, on 01603 675648 or email matrimonial@rogers-norton.co.uk.

*Office for National Statistics ‘Families & Households 2012’ Statistical Bulletin 1st November 2012.

Friday, October 21, 2011

Prenuptial Agreements:Radmacher - one year on

The 20th October 2011 was the one-year anniversary of the landmark ruling handed down by the Supreme Court in the case of Radmacher v Granatino [2010] UKSC 42 in which it was held that the prenuptial agreements could be given decisive weight when considering financial settlements upon divorce. To what extent does this case have implications for those seeking to protect their assets in the event of divorce and what has been the effect of the decision in practice?

Mr Granatino and Ms Radmacher (formerly Granatino) entered into a prenuptial agreement in 1998 at the instigation of the wealthy wife which provided that neither party was to acquire any benefit from the property of the other during the marriage or on its termination. At the time, the husband held a well-paid position in banking which he subsequently left to pursue an academic, but significantly less well-paid, career. Following the issue of divorce proceedings in 2007 the husband applied to the Court for it to determine a financial settlement even though the prenuptial agreement stated that the couple would waive any financial claims against each other in the event of their divorce. Initially, the Court held that the prenuptial agreement was defective and awarded the husband a capital award of £5.56 million plus £504,000 for housing in Germany and periodical payments of £70,000 per year for the couple’s two daughters. The wife successfully appealed and the Court of Appeal reduced the husband’s award in recognition of the “decisive weight” of the prenuptial agreement. The husband appealed to the Supreme Court who upheld the decision of the Court of Appeal.

The decision in Radmacher does not mean that pre or postnuptial agreements are automatically enforceable. The law dealing with financial settlements upon divorce is set out in the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 (MCA) and it is not possible for couples to oust the jurisdiction of the Court by entering into a prenuptial agreement or an agreement after the marriage (postnuptial). However, what the case of Radmacher did achieve was to set out the circumstances which will enhance or detract from the weight to be given to any agreement when considered alongside the ‘section 25’ factors of the MCA. For example, it is important that each party receives independent legal advice and that there is full disclosure of each party’s financial resources. It is also important that the agreement is entered into freely, in the absence of undue pressure or duress. It is therefore the role of the solicitor to carefully draft any proposed agreement to ensure that its terms will be followed by the Courts in future, should one party attempt to renege on the agreement and make an application to the court for a financial order.

The publicity surrounding Radmacher and prenuptial agreements in general has seen an increase in the number of enquiries and instructions received by the Matrimonial Team at Rogers & Norton from individuals seeking to protect their assets. The trend of people marrying later in life, sometimes for second or subsequent times, means that many individuals have pre-acquired assets which they bring to a marriage. Also, many individuals are keen to protect any future wealth such as inheritance from their family.

Prenuptial and postnuptial agreements can include provisions regarding existing wealth and assets, future inheritance, gifts during the marriage and the practical and financial arrangements for children. Our Matrimonial Team is experienced in advising in relation to a proposed agreement, drafting both prenuptial and postnuptial agreements and advising upon agreements prepared by other solicitors to ensure they are clear and fair in light of the guidance set out in the Radmacher judgment.

If you are considering entering into a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement and would like some advice then please feel free to contact Sophie Key or Amy Walpole on 01603 675648 or email matrimonial@rogers-norton.co.uk.

Monday, June 20, 2011

Shared parenting – a move in the right direction?

On 17th June 2011 the Shared Parenting Orders Bill will receive its second reading in the House of Commons.

When, a child’s residence, formerly known as ‘custody,’ cannot be agreed by his/her parents, it will be determined by the Court. The Courts are governed by the Children Act 1989 and, whilst the Court’s paramount consideration is the welfare of the child, it will take into consideration various other factors to determine with which parent a child shall live including the child’s wishes and feelings, the capability of the parents to meet his/her needs and any harm the child has suffered or is at risk of suffering. The Court does have the option to make a shared residence order where a child spends significant periods of time with each parent but typically, where a child’s place of residence is in dispute, the Court will be asked to specify with which parent the child shall live and, often, the level of contact s/he shall have with the non-resident parent. The Shared Parenting bill is seeking to change the way in which the Courts consider the arrangements for children.

The Bill was initially presented on 13th July 2010. The purpose of the proposed legislation is to ensure that, wherever possible, children benefit from the full involvement of both parents in their upbringing. A “shared parenting order” means an order providing for both parents to have a full involvement in the upbringing of a child particularly in respect of major long-term issues, and requiring that the child must spend a substantial and significant amount of time with both parents. This is to be distinguished from a shared residence order.
The presumption of shared parenting has been considered by the Family Justice Review in their interim report dated 31st March 2011. The Panel comments that currently the Court follows case law which sets out that it is almost always in the interests of a child whose parents are separated that he or she should have contact with the parent with whom the child is not living (Re P (Contact: Supervision) [1996] 2 FLR 314). The Court will only depart from this presumption where the potential for harm to the child outweighs the benefit of parental contact.

Shared parenting legislation is increasingly common elsewhere in the world. Australia, France, Denmark, Belgium and a number of US states are examples. However, the Family Justice Review Panel considered evidence from Australia and Sweden in particular about the harm caused to children resulting from the conflict between parents where the legislation has created a presumption of shared time. It concluded that these countries have experienced difficulties in interpreting and implementing the legislation which goes against the aim of family lawyers and policy makers to keep disputes regarding children away from the Courts.

As a result of this evidence, the panel has concluded that no legislation should be introduced that creates or risks creating the perception that there is a parental right to substantially shared or equal time for both parents. It is recommended that the existing legislation should be amended to include a general statement of intent, to reinforce the importance of the child continuing to have a meaningful relationship with both parents, alongside the need to protect the child from harm.

There are concerns that to adopt such a broad-brush approach will remove the current case-by-case approach which is tailored to the individual needs of the child. A presumption of shared parenting could move away from the current role of the Courts to make decisions in the best interests of children and may favour the best interests of the parents.

Sophie Key at Rogers & Norton comments " the principles of shared parenting would be beneficial to many families. That said, applying the presumption to all families could be detrimental to the welfare of some children – no two cases are the same, and the current legislation providing for every case to be considered on their individual factors is a much safer option. "

Whether the proposed shared parenting legislation comes into force remains to be seen but it would appear that the fight for children to have an equal relationship with both parents is as strong as ever.

Should you wish for any further information or advice on Children matters please contact Sophie Key on sok@rogers-norton.co.uk or 01603 675666.