Tuesday, July 28, 2020

Litigation Team Secures Dismissal of a Winding-Up Petition

The litigation team has recently secured the dismissal of a winding-up petition for almost £180,000 that had been issued against a company.

Personal Litigation and Dispute Resolution
Under s. 122 of the Insolvency Act 1986 (“the Act”), a company may be wound up by the Court if, amongst other reasons, it is unable to pay its debts. s. 123 of the Act defines what is meant by “unable to pay its debts” and this definition includes where a company has been served with a Statutory Demand “requiring the company to pay the sum so due and the company has for 3 weeks thereafter neglected to pay the sum or to secure or compound for it to the reasonable satisfaction of the creditor”. This is what had happened in this case.
Under s. 125 of the Act, “on hearing a winding-up petition the court may dismiss it, or adjourn the hearing conditionally or unconditionally, or make an interim order, or any other order that it thinks fit”.
The debt claimed was disputed on substantial grounds and this dispute is currently ongoing. The company’s position was therefore that it was not appropriate to make a winding-up order at this stage as it was able to pay its debts; the debt had simply not been paid because the company disputed that it was due.
It was of particular importance in this case that the petition was dismissed rather than the case being adjourned, because the company was in the process of securing finance for a development project. The lender would not release the funds whilst there was an outstanding petition registered against the company and the matter needed to be dealt with urgently as there was a very limited time for which the lender was willing to keep the funds available for the company.
After negotiations with the creditor we were able to persuade them to agree to the dismissal of the petition at this stage. However, the lender required evidence that the petition had actually been dismissed by an order of the Court, their reasoning being that even if the parties had signed a consent order, the Court could for whatever reason decline to endorse it.
We made an application to the County Court dealing with the petition for the consent order that had been agreed to be approved. However, in light of the current pandemic Courts are working at limited capacity and prioritising cases that they consider to be urgent. The Court was therefore unable to confirm whether they would be in a position to seal the order before the lender’s deadline. We were therefore required to make an urgent application to the High Court for the case to be transferred up to that Court and for an order to be made in the terms that had been agreed. Counsel was instructed to proceed with this on a Friday afternoon, the following Monday we were advised that the order had been approved by an Insolvency and Companies Court Judge and we had the sealed order the following day. This enabled the company to proceed with its funding.
We are able to advise on insolvency procedures for both companies and individuals, whether you are a creditor looking to recover monies owed to you or a debtor who is being pursued. Please contact Peter Hastings or myself (Elizabeth Gibson) in the Dispute Resolution team at Rogers & Norton for further information.

Wednesday, June 24, 2020

Litigation Team Success for Irish Company against UK Border Force

The Rogers & Norton HMRC and UK Border Force Litigation team were delighted to help with the restoration of goods worth more than one hundred thousand pounds for a company exporting goods via the UK to Eastern Europe.
Alcohol and Tobacco
The items were seized shortly after Christmas and created significant consequences for the company at a challenging time of year to find a solution to the problems they had with HMRC. The goods were destined for companies in Eastern Europe and unless restored, meant that our client would be in breach of contract should it not fulfil the order, with a risk to the company’s future We secured the restoration on making a detailed submission at Review.
Our specialist team that deal with HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) claims, in particular relating to the detention of goods, seizure of goods, understood the need to react quickly to get the goods restored, as the effect on cash flow together with the potential impact on jobs, would be problematic for any company.
We are currently pursuing a claim for damages for the unlawful seizure of goods, with the damages exceeding £1,000,000 and also challenging numerous seizures, assessments of Duty and VAT and requests for security payments. We have a wide experience in dealing with detentions, stoppages and the seizure of goods by UK Border Force.
The team deals with the worldwide importation of goods to the UK, including the huge market from China, Europe, America and Mexico. We work with clients who want goods restored at all major ports of entry, such as Felixstowe and London Gateway, together with Stansted, Gatwick & Heathrow.
We are experienced in Magistrates Court proceedings; First Tier Tax Tribunal; Court of Appeal; European Convention on Human Rights; Administrative Court and Injunctions and can assist with Tax, Coding and Duty and Vat claims and issues.

Tuesday, June 23, 2020

Busy construction team

It’s been a busy few months for the construction team despite Lockdown.

Construction
We have yet another example of how vitally important the use of a Pay Less notice is in the building industry, having recovered a substantial sum of money for a contractor and also succeeding for a sub-contractor as the main contractor had failed to issue a valid Pay Less Notice pursuant to Section 111 Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 due to one not being served.
We are currently acting on the recovering of a final contract on a 4 year project with a build cost of £12,500,000 and on a dispute over a defective roof for a shopping complex. In addition, we are dealing with various claims for breaches of contract in relation to design and naturally advising on delays arising from Covid 19 and Force Majeure and Frustration issues.
Our skilled and experienced Litigation team have a wide depth of knowledge relating to the construction industry – if you are experiencing issues with enforcing a contract or any construction and building claims, you can contact us on 01603 675639 or at ph@rogers-norton.co.uk.
We are also experience in drafting and advising on construction contracts including JCT contracts, and also Adjudication, Arbitration, Mediation and Expert Determination.

Monday, June 22, 2020

Success for Rogers and Norton’s Contentious Probate Team

22nd Jun 2020

It is sad that a dispute can arise following the death of a loved one. We are handling increasing levels of litigation in this area.
Judicial Review
A recent case saw our clients, brothers of the deceased, subjected to a claim for the entire estate by a party who alleged that she was a long term partner and that she and the deceased planned to marry. It was her case that she was left without reasonable financial provision from what was a sizeable estate.
On this occasion the contentious probate team were able to defeat the claim under The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 (“the Inheritance Act“), and having scrutinised the evidence including bank records and social media postings.
Rogers & Norton’s contentious probate team have the knowledge and expertise to handle disputes of all levels and size. They combine the skills and talents of the private client team with the experience of the litigation team, to ensure the client achieves the best expert advice and outcome.

Monday, June 8, 2020

Covid 19: Injunction Granted on the basis of the Corporate Governance and Insolvency Bill

On 2 June 2020 in the case of Re: A Company (injunction to restrain presentation of petition [2020] EWHC 1406 (Ch), the High Court granted an injunction to restrain the presentation of a winding up petition on the basis of prospective changes to the Insolvency Act 1986 to be made by the Corporate Insolvency and Governance Bill (“the Bill”).
Judicial Review

Background

The Bill was published by the Government on 20 May 2020. If passed in its current form, the Bill will, amongst other changes to the insolvency regime, enact short-term restrictions on the presentation of debt-based winding up petitions against companies. These restrictions are in response to the current coronavirus pandemic and are intended to bring some respite for companies currently struggling to pay their debts.
The restrictions on presenting debt-based winding up petitions provide that:
  • No winding-up petitions are to be presented on or after 27 April 2020 if they rely upon statutory demands served between 1 March 2020 and 30 June 2020 (or one month after the Bill comes into force, whichever is the later).
  • No winding-up petitions are to be presented between 27 April 2020 and 30 June 2020 (or one month after the Bill comes into force, whichever is the later) unless the creditor has reasonable grounds for believing that:
  • coronavirus has not had a financial effect on the company; or
  • that the company would have become unable to pay its debts even if coronavirus had not had a financial effect on the company.
  • The Court may order the winding-up of a company only if it is satisfied that the relevant ground relied upon would have applied even if coronavirus had not had a financial effect on the company.
The Bill is expected to become law by the end of this month, although in its current form the restrictions on presenting winding-up petitions are retrospective, to be regarded as coming into force on 27th April 2020.
The Bill also contains provisions for voiding winding-up orders made before it comes into force but which would not have been made had it been in force at the time.

Facts of the Case

The application was an urgent application by a company, “D”, to restrain the presentation of a winding up petition. D was a high street retailer and was a tenant of a retail unit owned by its landlord, “C”.
C had filed a winding-up petition in relation to unpaid rent and service charges which had recently fallen due under the lease. However, C did not pay the Court fee, so the petition had not been “presented”. On 15 April 2020, C had served a statutory demand in relation to these arrears.
In correspondence between the parties’ Solicitors, C had refused to give an undertaking not to present the petition. D therefore applied for an injunction to restrain the presentation of the petition on various grounds. The Court invited counsel for D to concentrate on a single ground, namely the significance of the Bill, and this was the sole ground on which the order was made.

Outcome

The Court granted the injunction sought by D, taking into account the intended policy behind the Bill. It also observed that even if presented, the petition was highly unlikely to be heard before the Bill is enacted. Accordingly, at any future hearing of the petition, the Court would have to apply the tests set out above.
The Court was provided with evidence as to the effects the coronavirus had had on the finances of D and concluded that there was a strong case that coronavirus had had a financial effect on the company and that the facts on which the petition was based would not have arisen if coronavirus had not had such an effect.

Comment

Although the Bill has not yet formally become law, the above case illustrates that the Courts will likely still apply its provisions when faced with a petition presented on or after 27th April 2020 or an application to restrain the presentation of such a petition. This will therefore be a strong disincentive for creditors to present winding-up petitions before the restrictions contained in the Bill are lifted. The voiding of any winding-up order made between 27th April 2020 and the coming into force of the Bill further strengthens this disincentive.
The wording of the Bill suggests that the onus will be on a creditor to show that coronavirus has not had a financial effect on a company or that the facts giving rise to the petition would have arisen in any event. However, should you find yourself in the position of having to seek an injunction to restrain the presentation of a winding-up petition or to oppose a petition that has been presented, it is important that you obtain as much evidence as possible to demonstrate the effect that coronavirus has had on your company and that the circumstances resulting in the presentation or threatened presentation of the petition would not have arisen if coronavirus had not had a financial effect on the company.
It is also notable that the Court must be satisfied that “coronavirus” did not have a financial effect on the company. This term is potentially very broad; it does not appear to be limited to the national lockdown and could therefore include more far-reaching effects of the virus, such as global supply issues.
At Rogers & Norton we have wide experience of representing both creditors and debtors in insolvency proceedings. If you are being pursued for a debt or are a creditor looking to recover money owing to you please contact the Dispute Resolution department to discuss your options further.

Tuesday, May 19, 2020

Commercial Landlord remedies during Covid-19

Many landlords are trying to find ways to work with their tenants during this time by offering concessions to reduce the risk of vacant properties and tenant insolvency. However where this is not an option, either due to the persistent default of an agreement or a tenant’s is refusing to communicate with their landlord the Government has issued guidance under the Coronavirus Act 2020 as to what a commercial landlord can and cannot do.

Inheritance and Probate Disputes

Forfeiture/Re-entry/Possession:

Forfeiture for commercial tenants has been suspended until at least 30 June 2020.
Commercial landlords can however seek a right of re-entry or forfeiture for other breaches of a lease.
Any existing possession orders are extended and the tenant does not need to give up possession before 30 June 2020 (this could be extended)

Winding-up Petitions:

Any applications made from 27 April 2020 will be reviewed by the court and if the tenant is unable to pay due to Covid-19 then the petition will not go any further, if the tenant is unable to pay for another reason the petition will continue but will be postponed until a later date not yet set.

Commercial Rent Arrears Recovery

This is still available but has been changed and the tenant must now owe at least 90 days arrears, this is intended to allow tenants flexibility with their finances during this time.

Statutory Demands

No statutory demand can be served on a tenants until at least 30 June 2020, however demands for payment can still be made against Guarantors and potentially the original or previous tenants as this is not prohibited under the act.

Rent Deposits

Depending upon the terms of the rent deposit, the landlord may be able to draw on this to receive payment of rent.

The aim of the above measures is to encourage landlords and tenants to communicate and come up with a suitable resolution where they are able to do so.
If you are a commercial landlord or a tenant facing issues, please contact us for advice.

Contacts

Commercial Property
Richard Etheridge 01603 675627
Bruce Faulkner 01603 675608
Litigation and Insolvency
Peter Hastings 01603 675639
Debt Recovery
Maria Taylor 01603 675613

Thursday, May 14, 2020

The Abused

Working with victims of abuse has always been a fulfilling part of my job as a solicitor. Being able to help victims of abuse escape their abuser and set them on the path to empowered recovery is in itself empowering. I recently had the pleasure of working with a victim of abuse who appeared in the Channel 5 documentary ‘The Abused,’ as we sought to protect her upon her ex-husband’s release from prison.
Defamatio, Libel & Reputation Management
Many of us still don’t fully recognise patterns of abuse and men especially can fall victim to abuse that they can’t identify. Below is a list of types of abusive behaviours and if you answer yes to some or all of them then you might be in an abusive relationship.
Emotional abuse
  • Does your partner belittle or put you down? Often they can suggest to you and other that they are ‘joking’ but it isn’t an isolated joke it’s continual.
  • Do they blame you for their actions or for arguments?
  • Downplaying their actions suggesting you are ‘ridiculous,’ ‘dramatic,’ ‘mental.’
  • Isolate you from family and friends. Perhaps prioritise their family and friends over yours, suggest that your family or friends are ‘boring,’ ‘don’t like them,’ or that your priority should be ‘them’ and not ‘running around after others’.
  • Requiring constant attention and punishing you if you are unable to provide it.
  • Accuse you or flirting, having affairs, looking for attention from others.
  • Controlling money – determining how money is spent, spending money that causes debt or asking you to obtain credit on their behalf or loan them money.
  • Threaten to kill or harm themselves.
  • Refusing to accept your boundaries or the word ‘no’, harassing you until you do things their way.
  • Destroy your things, stand over you or invade your personal space.
Physical abuse
  • Slapping, hitting or punching you
  • Pushing or shoving you
  • Biting or kicking you
  • Burn you
  • Choke or hold you down
  • Throw things at you
Sexual abuse
  • Touch you in a way you don’t want to be touched or pressure you into sexual acts
  • Make continual or unreasonable demands for sex and dominate you during sex in a way that hurts you
Forcing your partner to have sex when they don’t want to is rape. It isn’t persistence paying off.
How to escape
  • In an emergency always call 999
  • Contact Leeway 0300 5610 077 or Refuge 0808 2000 247 they may be able to offer you a safe haven
  • Call us or email us and ask for advice 01603 666001 or matrimonial@rogers-norton.co.uk. We can help with domestic abuse injunctions, orders with regards to children, divorce and financial orders. We have payment plans and discounted rates to help you. We have helped hundreds of people escape abusive relationships in a way and at a pace that is right for them. We are here to listen, help and support you.